« Spreadin' Love | Main | Spreadin' Love »

November 13, 2008

Comments

Amy P

We've been listening to LOTR on audio (the 52-hour Rob Inglis recording that has all the songs put to music), especially when we're in the car. C occasionally wants to just sit and listen when we're at home. We ask her questions and she is following the plot pretty well. We're also watching bits of the Peter Jackson movies with the kids as we advance through the books. There is a lot of violence and scariness, of course, but I haven't seen any ill effects, and the pluses have outweighed the minuses.

bj

"but I've decided to deal with it all by not dealing with it"

I want to do this, too. How do I learn?

Laura (geekymom)

My son got hooked on the Series of Unfortunate Events books. We have a hard time with the reading too. We've gotten Geeky Boy (13) to where if he finds the right thing, he won't be able to put the book down.

The 9-year old is harder. She's hooked on the Disney channel. Sigh.

meg

It's funny that Jonah seems to have no problem with the fictional trappings (wizards and wands) but the historical trappings (Sears catalog, collecting cans) give him pause.

Given his historical enthusiasm (if I remember correctly), how about some historical fiction about periods he's interested in? Rosemary Sutcliff's *Eagle of the Ninth* might be a good start... it's about a young boy who attaches himself to the Ninth Legion of the Roman Army.

learner

My kid uses the library to get the fiction that he loves and I would rarely if ever buy: comics and crap. You know, Captain Underpants. Or graphic novels by Joanne Sfar (Sardine in Outerspace, Little Vampire).

Maybe the prominent availability of this stuff is an NYC thing, but I would bet you can do the on-line request thing at almost every library in the country. And you can use it to ask for crap. It becomes an event when you go to the library to pick up what you think it crap but which your kid thinks is such a treasure.

It may be crap, but it is fiction.

Two last suggestions. Germonimo Stilton, which is not a comic but sort of junky and nonetheless fun and likely available in spades at the library. (It's an endless series and my son's quest to get more of them led to learning to do on-line requests himself.)

Second, Unlundun by China Mieville for reading aloud. You will likely love it just for yourself, as there is a girl hero.

In closing, you imply that he loves non-fiction. Can't you just let him love that, thereby nurturing his love of books?

Ragtime

My kid uses the library to get the fiction that he loves and I would rarely if ever buy: comics and crap. You know, Captain Underpants.

I got the Raggirls into reading SPECIFICALLY by buying them "comic and crap" more than the "good stuff." We are currently on our third copy of Captain Underpants, because the volumes can only handle so much "Flip-O-Rama" abuse.

Also, "Super Friends" and "Tiny Titans" comic books and Junie B. Jones and Magic Tree House audio books (as a reward to semi-stay up late on weekends).

With all of those picture- and audio- stuff, the Raggirls -- some of whom were resistant for formal reading or "bedtime stories" -- were all "reading" well before they could actually read.

Amy P

How about Asterix cartoon books or Tin Tin? I haven't read them myself, but I remember from my childhood that boy non-reader types seemed to love them, and with Asterix you get the Roman setting. (We have the DVD of The Twelve Tasks of Asterix, my six-year-old daughter loves it, and I think it is very clever.)

Ryan Carlton

My mother got my brothers to read fiction with Roald Dahl. Dirty Beasts and Revolting Rhymes and The Twits.

Elizabeth

How old is Jonah again?

D is almost 8, and very resistant to reading novels. But he reads Manga endlessly.

Wendy

My 9 year old refused to read most everything I offered her. I finally got her into Nancy Drew, then she got into some sort of FaithGrrlz series because the heroine was named Sophie. But after that, it was reading LOLCats every night. Then the school got involved with some sort of contest to read MA Book Awards books, and now she wants to read all of them. So I guess I recommend a contest. :)

laura

Jonah is 9. He's doing okay with Harry Potter, but it is pouting at the moment for having to read Shiloh. I read the book last night on my own, so that I could test him for comprehension. It was actually a wonderful book.

Thanks for the suggestions. Meg, my husband has already ordered the Roman suggestion.

Jonah is mad about Diary of a Wimpy Kid. He got the do it yourself diary a few weeks ago and has been a writing fiend. So that's a good thing.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    Tip Jar

    Change is Good

    Tip Jar

    Learn More

    Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

    BlogHer

    &





    &&



    Tip Jar

    Change is Good

    Tip Jar

    Learn More