« Waiting for the Other Shoe | Main | Midweek Journal »

November 13, 2008

Comments

Wendy

"At what point does breast feeding move to the creepy place?"

Not at 13 months! The freakout over Hayek is annoying.

Mamalooper

That freakout IS annoying. Most of the developing world breastfeeds well into the second year.

Methinks the freakout is more due to sexualizing of women's breasts. Relax, people, breastfeeding is normal.

bj

I think she was freaking people out by using the words "addicted to breastfeeding." It implied that she was doing it for her benefit rather than her daughters (in spite of the fact that her next sentence says that she was committed to BF'ing 'cause she thought it wonderful for her daughter). It would be creepy if someone was forcing their child to breastfeed for for their benefit and not the child's. That's why we talk of child-lead weaning.

I blame her using the word "addicted" incorrectly to mean something that she's "committed to and enjoys."

Ailurophile

I think Hayek's word choice of "addicted" was unfortunate. However, 14 months is still young. Our hunter-gatherer ancestors likely breastfed for three YEARS. It's not unheard of for a child in a hunting/gathering society to nurse until he or she is five. I read a paper that noted the Coahuiltecan Indians living near what is now Corpus Christi, Texas, who were in very harsh and scarce living conditions. Children *up to the age of twelve* were permitted to nurse when food was scarce.

It would certainly be considered weird for a modern twelve-year-old or even four-year-old to breastfeed (not to mention the teeth factor!) but let's not forget we moderns are spoiled with the availability of baby formula and pureed baby foods.

Harry b

People use "addicted" in that way all the time. And 13 months doesn't seem weird at all.

But, when Penelope Leach had a show in the states, my favourite moment was when a woman from the audience said that people give her strange looks and criticize her for breastfeeding her kid in public, and asked Leach what she should say in response. Leach gave her usual calm, reassuring, response, that some people are upset, but you shouldn't let that inhibit you, etc. Then, as an aside, she asked the age of the child. "5". When Leach realised this was 5 years, not 5 months, even her face betrayed some dismay.

MH

People are going to make different decisions that I would, but the important thing is to raise awareness of Selma Hayek.

Wendy

Confession time: I think "Fools Rush In" is a really enjoyable movie.

Wendy

Weird! The verification code that came up on that last reply was:

azpuma

bj

Salma, MH, Salma.

bj

MH

Oops. I was distracted.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    Tip Jar

    Change is Good

    Tip Jar

    Learn More

    Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

    BlogHer

    &





    &&



    Tip Jar

    Change is Good

    Tip Jar

    Learn More